Skip to content
The Draft Bomb
Back to the 2023 class
Retrospective scouting report · Class of 2023R4 · #135
QB· Round 4

Aidan
O'Connell.

Aidan O'Connell
Bomb Grade
56.2/100

Purdue official athletic logoPurdue· 6'3"· 213 lb

R4 · #135 · LVR

"A walk-on turned 546-attempt starter whose entire case was timing, toughness and anticipation — the Raiders spent a traded-up fourth on the bet that processing survives when arm talent does not."Pre-draft read

01Play style

A pure pocket passer who ran Purdue's spread timing attack almost entirely from shotgun, O'Connell wins with anticipation, footwork and a fast internal clock rather than arm talent. He throws in rhythm off three- and five-step drops, layers the ball into intermediate windows, and lives on option routes and dig concepts that reward a quarterback willing to release before the break.

The secondary trait is pocket toughness: he slides, resets his platform and delivers with bodies at his feet instead of bailing. There is no rushing dimension, and average arm strength caps the vertical menu, so everything routes back through processing. The signature is volume accuracy under duress.

02Scheme fit
Ideal system

Timing-and-rhythm West Coast or Shanahan-style play-action offense that gets the ball out on schedule from under center and shotgun.

Shotgun spreadPlay-action boot (fake only)Empty rhythm dropbackQuick-game trips
Best role

Year 1: QB2 with spot-start viability in a structured offense. Ceiling: two-year bridge starter on a scripted play-sheet.

Wrong fit

A vertical isolation offense that asks him to win outside the numbers and off-platform, or any system built on quarterback movement and designed runs.

His value survives only when the play-caller protects him with rhythm concepts and a functional run game.

03Film room

Aidan O'Connell - Purdue QB Highlights

Purdue reel showing the timing throws, footwork and intermediate anticipation that carried his college case.

Aidan O'Connell vs Tennessee - Music City Bowl

The 534-yard Music City Bowl against Tennessee, the ceiling game for his rhythm passing.

Raiders Rookie QB Aidan O'Connell Makes his First Career Start | 2023 Week 4

First NFL start against the Chargers as a rookie in 2023.

04The evaluation

O'Connell arrived at Purdue as a walk-on who had barely played high school quarterback and left as the program's most prolific passer of the decade, which tells you most of what the evaluation needed to say: this was a football-intelligence prospect, not a traits prospect. What he does well lives between the ears and below the waist — eyes moving in the right order, ball out before pressure arrives.

The production was real and it was earned in a system that asked him to throw. He completed 71.8 percent for 3,712 yards and 28 touchdowns in 2021, then carried a thinner offense to 3,856 yards on 546 attempts in 2022, a workload that inflated both his numbers and his interception total. The 534-yard Music City Bowl against Tennessee showed the ceiling of the timing game; the 15 picks the following fall showed what happens when a modest arm keeps forcing throws into tight windows.

Boards had him as a Day 3 backup, with the Brock Purdy comparison attached to nearly every write-up that cycle. Las Vegas agreed enough to trade back into the fourth round at 135, treating him as cheap contingency behind Jimmy Garoppolo. It was a sensible price for a quarterback whose floor was a competent spot starter and whose ceiling was capped by the same arm that capped him in college.

05Strengths
  1. 01

    Anticipation

    He throws to leverage and space instead of open receivers, releasing on the break of dig, curl and option routes with a rhythm few Day 3 quarterbacks show.

  2. 02

    Pocket poise

    Slides and climbs rather than bailing, keeping his eyes downfield with rushers at his feet and resetting his base before delivering under duress.

  3. 03

    Footwork discipline

    His drops are tied to the concept and his weight transfer is consistent, which is why his accuracy holds up in the intermediate game.

  4. 04

    Processing speed

    Reads full-field progressions in order, identifies the rotation post-snap and gets to his third option without panicking or drifting.

  5. 05

    Volume durability

    Handled 546 attempts as a senior behind an uneven line and never lost his mechanics or his willingness to stand in and take the hit.

06Concerns
  1. 01

    Arm strength

    Average velocity that shrinks the deep-out and back-shoulder menu; NFL closing speed turns his comfortable college throws into contested ones.

  2. 02

    Zero mobility

    He is a statue outside the pocket, offering nothing on designed movement and little on scramble drills when the first read is covered.

  3. 03

    Turnover volume

    Fifteen interceptions as a senior reflected a habit of trusting anticipation into windows that were already closing.

  4. 04

    Late-age profile

    Turned 25 during his rookie fall with no athletic upside left to develop, meaning the player he was in 2022 is essentially the player he is.

08College production
YrTeamGCmpAttYdsTDInt
2019Purdue6103164110184
2020Purdue48813691672
2021Purdue1231543937122811
2022Purdue1335254638562215
Career35858128595856532

Season lines sum exactly to the career line (858/1285, 9,585 yards, 65 TD, 32 INT). Totals are bowl-inclusive; the cfbstats regular-season pages show 3,708 in 2021 and 499 attempts in 2022 because they exclude the Music City Bowl, Big Ten Championship and Citrus Bowl.

A dash means the figure is not published by a source we trust — never a zero we invented.

/ Usage share, 2022
58.3%of team plays
92 percentile at positionPurdue
Pass plays · 97.7%Run plays · 5.1%Third down · 76.0%Passing downs · 84.9%
CFBD usage — share of the offense's plays involving the player
09Pro comparisons
/ Likely outcome
Jacoby BrissettArizona Cardinals

A trusted veteran QB2 who can start a dozen games without sinking a team and without lifting one either.

/ Ceiling
Brock PurdySan Francisco 49ers

The comp every 2023 report reached for: a late-round processor who thrives when the structure around him does the heavy lifting.

/ Floor
Nick MullensJacksonville Jaguars

Anticipation-first backup whose interception rate follows him from job to job once defenses shrink the intermediate windows.

10In hindsight

Everything above is the pre-draft evaluation. This section is what actually happened — updated year over year.

Pro Bowls
0
All-Pro
0
Seasons
Career AV

The Raiders needed him immediately. Jimmy Garoppolo's ankle gave out early in 2023 and O'Connell was starting by Week 4, then took over for good after the coaching change, finishing his rookie year with 11 appearances, 2,218 yards, 12 touchdowns and seven interceptions — including a 25-point rout of Kansas City on Christmas Day that remains the high-water mark of his career. In 2024 he split the job again through injury and inconsistency, going 154 of 243 for 1,612 yards with eight touchdowns and four picks across nine games. By 2025, with Geno Smith installed as the starter, his season shrank to a single relief appearance: 10 of 22 for 102 yards.

The retrospective verdict is that the fourth round was exactly the right room for him. Seventeen starts and nearly 4,000 career yards from pick 135 is a clear return on a Day 3 quarterback, and Las Vegas got two years of competent, cheap starting play out of a contract that cost them almost nothing. What never changed is the thing the tape flagged in 2022 — the arm does not create, so when the surrounding talent is thin, the offense stalls at exactly the moment it needs a quarterback to invent something. He settled into the league as a legitimate backup with starting experience, which is the honest ceiling of an anticipation-first passer without a second gear.

The Draft Bomb · retrospective scouting profile