Skip to content
The Draft Bomb
Back to the 2022 class
Retrospective scouting report · Class of 2022R4 · #123
RB· Round 4

Isaiah
Spiller.

Isaiah Spiller, Texas A&M scouting portrait
Bomb Grade
56.2/100

Texas A&M official athletic logoTexas A&M· 6'0"· 217 lb

/ Recruiting profile
★★★★☆stars.9351
National · #152HS class · 2019
Klein Collins, TX
247Sports composite via CFBD
R4 · #123 · LAC

"Three straight productive SEC seasons at 5.5 yards a carry, then a combine that offered no 40 time, a 30-inch vertical and every reason to wonder whether the patience would survive without an elite line."Pre-draft read

01Play style

Spiller was a 217-pound zone runner who made his living on patience. He pressed the line, let blocks develop in front of him and stepped through the crease with a smooth, gliding stride rather than a violent burst, and he did it well enough to average 5.5 yards a carry across three SEC seasons.

The second gear never showed up. He was a build-up runner who took time to reach top speed and could be caught from behind on runs that should have scored, and he did not make defenders miss in tight quarters. What he did offer was true three-down value: 74 career receptions, clean hands out of the backfield and a willingness to stay in and pick up a blitz. The signature was reliability at an SEC workload, not explosiveness.

02Scheme fit
Ideal system

Wide-zone offense with a strong line that creates defined creases and values a back who reads blocks patiently and protects the quarterback.

Zone-scheme tailbackThird-down backPass protectorCheck-down receiver
Best role

Year 1: rotational back splitting early downs and handling third down. Ceiling: 1A in a committee behind a quality zone-blocking front.

Wrong fit

A gap-scheme offense that asks a back to hit an assigned hole with immediate acceleration, or a bad line that requires him to create yardage alone.

03Film room

Isaiah Spiller 2020 Texas A&M Highlights

The first-team All-SEC season, 1,036 yards on 188 carries in ten games.

Isaiah Spiller Highlights Texas A&M RB 2020-21

Two-season cut-up of the zone vision and receiving work that drove his draft grade.

Chargers Rookie RB Isaiah Spiller ALL TOUCHES vs. Falcons

Rookie NFL touches showing how quickly the creases closed at the next level.

04The evaluation

Spiller was the rare running back who produced immediately and never stopped. He started nine games as a true freshman in 2019 and ran for 946 yards and ten touchdowns, then went over 1,000 yards in each of the next two seasons and left Texas A&M with 16 career 100-yard games, the most by an Aggie since Greg Hill in the early nineties.

The résumé was first-team All-SEC in 2020, second-team in 2021 and a Doak Walker semifinalist nod, all of it built on a consistent 5.5 yards a carry against the best defensive fronts in the country. His best individual performances were the kind scouts remember: 217 yards against UTSA, 168 at Missouri, a game-winning touchdown catch at Colorado. He was a complete back at 20 years old with three years of pass-protection reps.

The problem was testing. He did not run the 40 at the combine, posted a 30-inch vertical and a 114-inch broad jump, and his pro day did not change the athletic picture. Boards saw a productive, dependable back without the burst that separates Day 2 backs from committee pieces. He came off the board at 123 to a Chargers team that needed a complement to Austin Ekeler.

05Strengths
  1. 01

    Zone vision

    He pressed the line and let blocks set up, reading the front like a veteran and taking what the scheme produced instead of freelancing.

  2. 02

    Three-down usability

    Seventy-four career receptions plus real pass-protection reps meant he never had to leave the field on third down.

  3. 03

    Production floor

    He cleared 946, 1,036 and 1,011 yards in his three seasons at 5.5 a carry, against SEC defenses every week.

  4. 04

    Contact finishing

    At 217 pounds he ran through ankle tackles and consistently churned for extra yardage after the first defender arrived.

  5. 05

    Youth and mileage

    He entered the draft at 20 years old with three full seasons of starting experience, an unusually early developmental window.

06Concerns
  1. 01

    Long speed

    He built up gradually rather than hitting a second gear, and defensive backs ran him down on carries that should have finished as scores.

  2. 02

    Testing profile

    A 30-inch vertical and 114-inch broad jump, with no 40 time on record, gave teams nothing to argue against the explosiveness concerns.

  3. 03

    Elusiveness in space

    He did not make the first defender miss in a phone booth, relying on the scheme to create the crease rather than creating his own.

  4. 04

    Ball security

    Eight career fumbles across 615 college touches was a number every NFL staff flagged on a back who would be asked to carry the load.

07Athletic testing
Height
6'0"
Weight
217 lb
Vertical
30"
Broad
9'6"
06Athletic profilevs. RB on Big Board
40VERTBRD3CSHTLBNCH

— — — positional median (p50)

40 yd
—s
Vertical
30inp50
Broad jump
114inp50
Three-cone
—s
Shuttle
—s
Bench
—rep
08College production
YrTeamGAttYdsTDRecRecYds
2019Texas A&M131749461029203
2020Texas A&M101881036920193
2021Texas A&M121791011625189
Career—3554129932574585

The 2020 and 2021 lines are verified on cfbstats (Texas A&M team 697, player 1105797). The 2019 freshman year comes from the full published Tankathon and official Texas A&M lines, which agree on 13 games, 174 carries for 946 yards and ten touchdowns with 29 receptions for 203 yards, because cfbstats does not publish that season for this player. The three seasons sum exactly to the career line: 35 games, 541 carries for 2,993 yards and 25 rushing touchdowns with 74 receptions for 585 yards and one score.

A dash means the figure is not published by a source we trust — never a zero we invented.

/ Usage share, 2021
26.9%of team plays
93 percentile at positionTexas A&M
Pass plays · 8.5%Run plays · 45.1%Third down · 14.6%Passing downs · 17.8%
CFBD usage — share of the offense's plays involving the player
09Pro comparisons
/ Likely outcome
Joshua KelleyLos Angeles Chargers

Dependable college producer who settles in as a rotational NFL back without a defined role.

/ Ceiling
Devonta FreemanAtlanta Falcons

Patient zone back with receiving value who becomes the lead runner on a playoff offense.

/ Floor
Rodney AndersonCincinnati Bengals

Productive college runner whose lack of NFL burst ends the career before a second contract.

10In hindsight

Everything above is the pre-draft evaluation. This section is what actually happened — updated year over year.

Pro Bowls
0
All-Pro
0
Seasons
—
Career AV
—

He never got going in Los Angeles. As a rookie in 2022 he was inactive for most of the first half of the season and finished with 18 carries for 41 yards behind Austin Ekeler and Joshua Kelley. The 2023 season brought more work and worse results: 37 carries for 96 yards, a 2.6-yard average, no touchdowns. The Chargers let him go, Las Vegas signed him for 2024 and he spent that year on the practice squad without an appearance. By 2026 he was in the UFL with the Dallas Renegades. His NFL career totals are 55 carries, 137 yards, zero touchdowns and nine receptions.

In hindsight the testing numbers were telling the truth. At Texas A&M the offensive line and the zone scheme gave him the crease his patience needed, and the SEC production was real. In the NFL the crease closes a half second earlier, and a back without burst or independent creation has nothing left. The pass-protection and receiving work that made him a three-down projection never mattered because he never earned the down-one snaps. A Day 3 pick on a productive back is a reasonable bet; this one returned nothing.

The Draft Bomb · retrospective scouting profile