Skip to content
The Draft Bomb
Back to the 2020 class
Retrospective scouting report · Class of 2020Consensus #041
RB· Round 2

Jonathan
Taylor.

Jonathan Taylor, Wisconsin scouting portrait
Bomb Grade
75.1/100
Pre-draft #41

Wisconsin official athletic logoWisconsin· 5'10"· 226 lb· 4.39s 40

/ Recruiting profile
★★★☆☆stars.8884
National · #369HS class · 2017
Salem, NJ
247Sports composite via CFBD
R2 · #41 · Indianapolis Colts

"A three-year workhorse who turned Wisconsin's zone scheme into a track meet: press the crease, plant once, and outrun the angle that every defense swore it had."Pre-draft read

01Play style

Feature back in Wisconsin's outside- and mid-zone run game, asked to carry the offense on volume and to win with vision plus top-end speed rather than elusiveness in a phone booth. He presses the line square, lets the double team develop, and cuts once — no dancing, no wasted steps — then accelerates through the second level in two strides. At 226 pounds he runs behind his pads and falls forward on contact.

The separator is long speed at that mass: once he clears the linebacker level he pulls away from safeties instead of being run down, which turns ordinary creases into 60-yard plays. Run-game value is elite; passing-down value was still developing, with receiving usage that only opened up as a junior.

02Scheme fit
Ideal system

Outside- and mid-zone run game with a downhill quarterback keeper element that forces the second level to stay honest.

Single-back dotI-formation tailbackPistol zoneTwo-minute check-down back
Best role

Year 1: immediate 250-carry lead back in a run-first offense. Ceiling: a rushing title and All-Pro production as the offense's identity.

Wrong fit

A pass-heavy spread that plays from behind and asks its back to pick up free rushers and win as a route-runner on 40 percent of snaps.

Give him a defined crease and a lead blocker and the scheme stops mattering; make him improvise behind a broken front and the yards flatten.

03Film room

Jonathan Taylor 2019 Wisconsin Highlights

Junior-year reel: the one-cut plant and the long speed that separates once he clears the second level.

Wisconsin RB Jonathan Taylor 2019 Highlights

Zone-run volume tape with the expanded receiving usage that showed up as a junior.

Jonathan Taylor Wisconsin 2017 Freshman Highlights

True-freshman 1,977-yard season, already running behind his pads at full size.

04The evaluation

Taylor arrived in Madison as a lightly recruited New Jersey sprinter and left as one of the most productive backs in the history of the sport. He is a compact, thickly built one-cut runner with a track background that shows in his stride length and closing burst, and his game is built on decisiveness: he reads the first-level surface, commits, and gets to full speed faster than a man his size should.

The production is the headline. He ran for 1,977 yards as a true freshman in 2017, 2,194 as a sophomore in 2018 and 2,003 as a junior in 2019, finishing with 926 carries for 6,174 yards and 50 rushing touchdowns in 41 games, plus back-to-back Doak Walker Awards. The 2019 season also answered the question that dogged him early, as he caught 26 passes for 252 yards and five scores after eight catches in each of his first two years. The flag was ball security: 18 fumbles across three seasons, 15 of them lost, is a real number and it followed him through the process.

Boards had him as the best pure runner in the class and the safest bet for volume production, but the positional discount of the era pushed him out of round one. Indianapolis, with a rebuilt offensive line and a run-first identity under Frank Reich, took him 41st and handed him the job immediately.

05Strengths
  1. 01

    One-cut decisiveness

    presses the double team, plants once and is gone; no wasted footwork between the read and the crease in a zone scheme.

  2. 02

    Long speed at size

    226 pounds with track-caliber acceleration, so cleared creases turn into explosive runs instead of 15-yard gains and a safety tackle.

  3. 03

    Volume durability

    handled 299, 307 and 320 carries in three straight seasons and never lost a season to injury while carrying an entire offense.

  4. 04

    Contact balance

    runs behind his pads, absorbs arm tackles through the hole and consistently finishes forward rather than going down on first contact.

  5. 05

    Late receiving growth

    2019 usage (26 catches, five touchdowns) showed real hands and route feel after two seasons of almost no passing-game work.

06Concerns
  1. 01

    Ball security

    18 career fumbles with 15 lost is a disqualifying trend for a volume back, and the carriage was loose through the second level.

  2. 02

    Tight-space creativity

    not a make-you-miss back in a phone booth; when the first read is walled off he will take the two-yard gain instead of creating.

  3. 03

    Pass protection

    willing but inconsistent in blitz pickup, with late recognition of second-level pressure and hit-or-miss anchor against bigger rushers.

  4. 04

    Scheme dependence

    the bulk of his tape came behind a dominant Wisconsin front with clean interior surfaces and defined creases to attack.

07Athletic testing
Height
5'10"
Weight
226 lb
40 yd
4.39s
Vertical
36"
Broad
10'3"
3-cone
7.01s
Shuttle
4.24s
Bench
17
Relative Athletic Score
9.53
/10 · official

Relative Athletic Score (Kent Lee Platte) benchmarks combine/pro-day numbers against every measured prospect at the position since 1987. 10.00 is elite; 5.00 is average.

06Athletic profilevs. RB on Big Board
40VERTBRD3CSHTLBNCH

— — — positional median (p50)

40 yd
4.39sp50
Vertical
36inp50
Broad jump
123inp50
Three-cone
7.01sp50
Shuttle
4.24sp50
Bench
17repp50
08College production
YrTeamGAttYdsTDRecRecYds
2017Wisconsin14299197713895
2018Wisconsin13307219416860
2019Wisconsin1432020032126252
Career—4192661745042407

Totals include bowl games; season sums match the career line exactly. Back-to-back Doak Walker Award winner (2018, 2019).

A dash means the figure is not published by a source we trust — never a zero we invented.

/ Usage share, 2019
36.8%of team plays
99 percentile at positionWisconsin
Pass plays · 10.2%Run plays · 53.8%Third down · 21.7%Passing downs · 15.1%
CFBD usage — share of the offense's plays involving the player
09Pro comparisons
/ Likely outcome
Joseph AddaiIndianapolis Colts

Efficient, decisive zone runner who produces heavily inside a structured scheme without carrying the passing game.

/ Ceiling
Ezekiel ElliottDallas Cowboys

The three-down volume workhorse who wins the rushing title and becomes the offense's identity in year two.

/ Floor
Rashaad PennySeattle Seahawks

Explosive one-cut speed that never stabilizes because of ball security and availability.

10In hindsight

Everything above is the pre-draft evaluation. This section is what actually happened — updated year over year.

Pro Bowls
3
All-Pro
1
Seasons
—
Career AV
—

Indianapolis got the volume back it drafted almost immediately. He ran for 1,169 yards as a rookie in 2020 and then exploded in 2021, leading the NFL with 1,811 rushing yards and 18 touchdowns on 332 carries while adding 40 catches for 360 yards, earning first-team All-Pro honors in his second season. The middle years were the hard part: ankle injuries and a contract standoff limited him to 11 games and 861 yards in 2022 and 10 games and 741 yards in 2023, and the relationship with the front office turned public before it was repaired. He came back to form with 1,431 yards in 14 games in 2024 and a 1,585-yard, 18-touchdown season on 323 carries in 2025, then signed a two-year, $44 million extension that runs through 2028. Through Week 2 of 2026 he has 43 carries for 190 yards and four scores.

In hindsight the evaluation was right about the player and the board was wrong about the price. Taylor has 7,788 rushing yards and 73 touchdowns in 86 games with three Pro Bowls, and the fumbling that scared teams off never became a career problem at the next level. He is not a back who creates something out of nothing, and the seasons in which the Colts' line and quarterback play sagged show it, but as a volume runner in a defined scheme he has been one of the best of his generation. The 41st pick returned first-round production for six years.

Data note: from Cleveland

The Draft Bomb · retrospective scouting profile