Skip to content
The Draft Bomb
Back to the 2020 class
Retrospective scouting report · Class of 2020Consensus #025
WR· Round 1

Brandon
Aiyuk.

Brandon Aiyuk, Arizona State scouting portrait
Bomb Grade
80.8/100
Pre-draft #25

Arizona State official athletic logoArizona State· 6'0"· 205 lb· 4.50s 40

R1 · #25 · San Francisco 49ers

"A junior college transfer with one full season as a starter who finished second in the country in yards after the catch, and whose entire projection lived in what happened once the ball arrived."Pre-draft read

01Play style

Yards-after-catch weapon who turned short and intermediate targets into explosive plays. He caught the ball in stride, got vertical immediately instead of dancing, and had the contact balance to run through the first arm tackle, which is how he finished second in the FBS in yards after the catch as a senior.

He was a long strider rather than a twitchy separator, best on crossers, slants and manufactured touches where the ball arrived on the move. The release package against press was unfinished and the route tree was narrow. He also returned punts, including one for a score, and had the ball skills to track the deep shot over either shoulder. The signature was a senior season where six of his eight scores traveled more than thirty yards.

02Scheme fit
Ideal system

Wide-zone play-action offense with motion and manufactured touches that gets him the ball on the move and lets him create after the catch.

Z receiverSlotJet motionPunt returner
Best role

Year 1: run-after-catch specialist on crossers and screens in a designed-touch offense. Ceiling: a 1,300-yard number one target.

Wrong fit

Isolation-heavy passing game that lines him up on the boundary against press and asks him to win contested fades on his own.

His value is in the twenty yards after the ball arrives, so the scheme has to get it to him in stride.

03Film room

Arizona State WR Brandon Aiyuk 2019 Highlights

The senior season that produced the first-round grade and the yards-after-catch profile.

Brandon Aiyuk 2019 Highlights

Explosive plays including the pair of eighty-yard touchdown catches.

Brandon Aiyuk: Arizona State Best Highlights

Career cut-up covering the receiving and punt return work.

04The evaluation

Aiyuk took the long road into the 2020 class. He came out of Reno to Sierra College, arrived at Arizona State as a junior in 2018 behind N'Keal Harry, and only became a full-time starter as a senior, which meant two years of Power Five tape and a twenty-two-year-old evaluation.

The senior year was emphatic: 65 catches for 1,192 yards and eight touchdowns, the fifth-most receiving yards in a season in ASU history, second nationally in yards after the catch with 710, and first in the Pac-12 at 3.04 yards per route run. He was an AP All-American and a Pac-12 special teams player of the week as a punt returner. The explosive-play profile was real and repeatable rather than a handful of screens.

The concerns were sample and polish. One productive season, a limited route tree, and a release package that had not been tested against NFL press coverage left teams projecting rather than confirming. He also underwent core muscle surgery that limited his pre-draft workouts. San Francisco valued the run-after-catch traits enough to trade up, sending the 31st pick and a fourth-rounder to Minnesota, and took him 25th overall as Kyle Shanahan's replacement for Emmanuel Sanders.

05Strengths
  1. 01

    Yards after catch

    Finished second in the FBS with 710 yards after the catch as a senior, averaging 10.9 per reception without relying on screens.

  2. 02

    Contact balance

    Runs through the first arm tackle and stays upright through glancing hits, converting routine completions into explosive gains.

  3. 03

    Deep tracking

    Locates and adjusts to the ball over either shoulder, with two touchdown catches of more than eighty yards in a single season.

  4. 04

    Return value

    Took a punt back for a touchdown and earned Pac-12 special teams player of the week honors, adding a third-phase role.

  5. 05

    Play speed

    Plays faster with the ball than his testing suggests, getting vertical immediately instead of wasting motion after the catch.

06Concerns
  1. 01

    Route tree

    Lived on crossers, slants and manufactured touches, with almost no film of him running the full professional route tree.

  2. 02

    Press release

    The hand-fighting package against physical corners is unfinished, and Power Five corners rarely challenged him at the line.

  3. 03

    One-year sample

    A junior college transfer with only one season as a full-time starter, so the projection rests on a single body of work.

  4. 04

    Pre-draft availability

    Core muscle surgery limited his workouts, leaving teams without a complete athletic testing profile to confirm the tape.

07Athletic testing
Height
6'0"
Weight
205 lb
40 yd
4.50s
Vertical
40"
Broad
10'8"
Bench
11
Relative Athletic Score
8.46
/10 · official

Relative Athletic Score (Kent Lee Platte) benchmarks combine/pro-day numbers against every measured prospect at the position since 1987. 10.00 is elite; 5.00 is average.

06Athletic profilevs. WR on Big Board
40VERTBRD3CSHTLBNCH

— — — positional median (p50)

40 yd
4.50sp50
Vertical
40inp50
Broad jump
128inp50
Three-cone
—s
Shuttle
—s
Bench
11repp50
08College production
YrTeamGRecYdsTD
2018Arizona State133300
2019Arizona State126560
Career—259860

Parsed from Sports-Reference CFB career page via Firecrawl.

A dash means the figure is not published by a source we trust — never a zero we invented.

/ Usage share, 2019
12.5%of team plays
93 percentile at positionArizona State
Pass plays · 25.5%Run plays · 0.5%Third down · 11.0%Passing downs · 17.4%
CFBD usage — share of the offense's plays involving the player
09Pro comparisons
/ Likely outcome
Emmanuel SandersSan Francisco 49ers

Reliable second-contract starter who produces 1,000-yard seasons in the right scheme without ever being an alpha X.

/ Ceiling
Robert WoodsLos Angeles Rams

The ceiling in a Shanahan tree: a complete, tough-minded starter who becomes the engine of the intermediate passing game.

/ Floor
Curtis SamuelCarolina Panthers

The downside if the route tree never expands: a gadget-adjacent contributor dependent on designed touches.

10In hindsight

Everything above is the pre-draft evaluation. This section is what actually happened — updated year over year.

Pro Bowls
0
All-Pro
0
Seasons
—
Career AV
—

The football answered every question and the business answered none of them. Aiyuk grew into exactly the receiver San Francisco hoped for: 748 yards as a rookie in twelve games, 826 in 2021, 1,015 and eight touchdowns in 2022, and a career year in 2023 with 75 catches for 1,342 yards and a 17.9-yard average that helped carry the 49ers to Super Bowl LVIII. That production earned a contract extension before the 2024 season worth a reported $120 million after a summer-long holdout and public trade requests.

Then it collapsed. He tore the ACL and MCL in his right knee in Week 7 of 2024 and has not played since. He missed all of 2025 and the 49ers placed him on the reserve/left squad list on December 13, voiding roughly $27 million in guarantees and the option bonus after the team said he did not attend treatment or meetings. He has publicly refused to apply for reinstatement, saying in July 2026 that he will never do business with the organization again, which leaves him under team control and unable to sign anywhere. Kyle Shanahan answered a September 2026 question about activating him with one word: no. The career line reads 69 games, 294 catches, 4,305 yards and 25 touchdowns, all before his twenty-seventh birthday. On pure evaluation this was a hit; on outcome it is one of the strangest endings in the round.

Data note: from Minnesota

The Draft Bomb · retrospective scouting profile