Carr’s win over Miami edges Smith’s monster season in a race split by résumé and production
Notre Dame’s quarterback owns the cleanest signature win, while Ohio State’s receiver still has the loudest season; after that, the race tightens around Miami, Georgia and Utah.
This is the week the Heisman race stopped looking like a crowd and started looking like a debate. C.J. Carr has the cleanest signature win, Jeremiah Smith has the loudest season, and the gap between résumé and production is now small enough to argue about in good faith. The quarterbacks behind them still have paths, but they need cleaner finishes than the ones they have given us lately.
The Top 5


C.J. Carr, QB, Notre Dame (9-1)
Carr gets the nod because his season has both volume and timing. He has 23 passing touchdowns against just 2 interceptions, and the best win on his card is still the 31-24 takedown of Miami, the kind of result that changes how the whole race feels. Notre Dame sitting at 9-1 gives every week after that a little more weight, and Carr has mostly answered it with control instead of noise.
The Boston College blowout was not dramatic, but it kept the Irish in command and kept his case clean.


Jeremiah Smith, WR, Ohio State (7-3)
Smith would have a stronger claim if this were only about the size of the stat line. It is not, and Ohio State’s 7-3 record, plus the two losses in the last three games, keeps him just behind Carr even after a season with 15 touchdowns and 1,317 receiving yards. The record-setting night at Northwestern reminded everyone that he can bend a race on his own, but the Buckeyes still have to carry the weight of a frustrating season.
He remains the one non-quarterback who can still force the conversation open.


Darian Mensah, QB, Miami (9-1)
Mensah has the prettiest passing profile in the group, and Miami’s 9-1 record keeps him in the center of the picture. He has 29 passing touchdowns against only 2 interceptions, and the Hurricanes have already beaten enough good teams to matter, including Clemson and North Carolina. The loss at Notre Dame hurt because it came against Carr directly, but it did not erase the fact that Mensah is driving one of the most dangerous offenses in the country.
His 382-yard night against Duke was another reminder that the ceiling is still there when Miami needs him to go take the game.

Gunner Stockton, QB, Georgia (9-1)
Stockton lives on the strength of Georgia’s best wins, and they are real. The 20-17 win at Alabama and the 42-7 rout of Ole Miss are the kind of results that make a quarterback look like a front-line Heisman player, even when his raw totals do not separate him as loudly as Carr or Mensah. Georgia is still No. 1, and Stockton has kept the offense stable enough to let that ranking breathe.
The 48-21 win over Missouri did not add drama, but it did keep the Bulldogs moving like a team built for the final month.


Devon Dampier, QB, Utah (10-0)
Dampier is the one player here who can argue undefeated status as his biggest asset. Utah is 10-0, and he has given them both passing production and real run-game value with 22 passing touchdowns and 9 rushing scores. The best wins are there — 28-20 over BYU and 40-39 at Arizona — but the schedule has not given him quite the same heavyweight punch as Carr, Mensah or Stockton.
Still, when a team keeps winning and its quarterback keeps finishing, he stays on the board until someone proves otherwise.
The Last Game
C.J. Carr finished with Notre Dame’s 41-7 win over Boston College, and the score itself tells the story: another clean day for a team that is no longer chasing its own identity. The Miami game earlier in this stretch is still the one that moved his case the most, but the most recent result kept him steady instead of exposing any wobble.
Jeremiah Smith capped the week in Ohio State’s 28-19 win over Northwestern, where he set another record and logged his sixth 100-yard performance of the season. That is how he keeps hanging around the top of this race: even in a season with too many team bruises, he keeps showing up with a new line to underline.
Darian Mensah closed with Miami’s 36-25 win over Duke, and this one mattered because it followed the Notre Dame loss with a response instead of a stumble. He threw for 382 yards and a touchdown, which is exactly the kind of rebound a contender needs after a tough road result.
Gunner Stockton ended with Georgia’s 48-21 win over Missouri, a game that kept the Bulldogs looking like a team that can win in multiple ways. He did not need a fireworks show; he needed steadiness, and Georgia got that from him in a game that preserved the team’s standing near the top.
Devon Dampier finished in Utah’s 40-39 win over Arizona, and this was the most volatile game in the top five. He threw for 204 yards and 2 touchdowns, ran for 100 yards and 2 more scores, and also turned it over twice, which is the kind of line that explains both his appeal and his risk. Utah survived because he was central to everything, for better and for worse.
The Moment of the Week
Utah 40-39 at Arizona was the result that moved the race most this week. Dampier ran, threw, gave the ball away twice and still walked out unbeaten; it is the kind of night that can sink a candidacy or make it unforgettable, and Utah remains the only team in this group without a loss.
The Name Nobody Is Watching
Giovanni Lopez, QB, Wake Forest (9-1), deserves a harder look than he is getting. He has 19 passing touchdowns, only 1 interception, plus 8 rushing touchdowns, and Wake Forest’s 9-1 record means his production is not empty volume. The recent 49-7 win over SMU keeps the Deacons in the national picture, and Lopez is the kind of quarterback who can sneak into a serious Heisman conversation if the top names keep beating each other up.
So who is the real front-runner right now: the quarterback with the cleanest win, or the receiver with the biggest season?
Newsletter
Liked this profile?
Get the next analyses and board movement, once a week.
No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.
